Opens in a new tab

Is an Accommodation Reasonable?

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and analogous state laws protect qualified employees with disabilities from discrimination. This includes providing reasonable accommodations to help them perform their jobs effectively. But how do you know when an accommodation is “reasonable”? 

Step 1: Determine the Employee’s Needs

Review the job description:

All job descriptions should be current and include a description of essential functions and physical requirements. If a requested accommodation prevents an employee from performing the essential functions of the position they were hired for, the accommodation may not be reasonable. 

Understand coverage under ADA & state laws:

Assess whether the employee meets the definition of having a disability under the ADA and any analogous state laws (e.g. California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act).

Initiate the interactive process:

Engage in a collaborative discussion with the employee to understand their needs and explore potential accommodations. California provides a useful template for how to engage in an interactive discussion with an employee:

Interactive process template (English)

Request-For-Reasonable-Accommodation-Package_ENG.pdf

Download PDF • 2.22MB

Interactive process template (Spanish)

Request-For-Reasonable-Accommodation-Package_SP.pdf

Download PDF • 1.11MB

Step 2: Assess Disability & Accommodation Options

Seek professional verification:

Request input from the employee’s healthcare provider. This eliminates guesswork by relying on a professional to guide the scope and duration of an accommodation.

Assess undue hardship:

A requested accommodation should be granted unless doing so will significantly burden the organization (including if the accommodation prevents the employee from performing the essential functions of their position).

Step 3: Communicate & Document

Send a formal notification:

If an accommodation is approved, provide a written document outlining the specific accommodation, start date, and (if applicable) estimated end date.

Review & modify as needed: 

Regularly monitor the situation and be open to adjustments based on the employee’s evolving needs and the organization’s requirements.

Remember:

An inclusive workplace fosters a positive environment for everyone. By following this guide and engaging in open communication, you can effectively address employee accommodation requests while maintaining a productive work environment.

Have a question you’d like us to answer?

Click the button below to submit a request for an upcoming edition of HR Snapshot!

Don’t miss an update—Subscribe to HR Snapshot, today!

“As a small nonprofit health care agency, we went through a significant growth spurt in the past two years. Our Human Resources were truly struggling to keep up with the new demands, responsibilities, and labor law regulations. Not to mention, the added workload of personnel onboarding, offboarding, and disciplinary actions that are involved with growth. We had worked with Nancy for a short while, when we had a gap in HR coverage, and were truly impressed by the caliber of her knowledge and demeanor. So we worked with the Envision Initiative team to find a more permanent solution to our HR needs. Once Molly, Nancy’s partner, became an integrated member of the HPC team, she not only streamlined all of our HR processes, but she also effectively made Health Projects Center a modern small corporation with all of the much-needed support that keeps our employees supported and in compliance with all of the necessary requirements that are needed. Thank you, Envision Initiative team, for all that you have done for us.”

Mitch Matthews, Associate Director, Health Projects Center, Santa Cruz

“Working with Nancy Scholink and Envision Initiative has been a positive and productive partnership for Gateway Center. Nancy brings a thoughtful, solutions-oriented approach to human resources and has been a reliable partner, particularly when responsiveness and follow-through are critical. 
 
During a period of organizational transition, Gateway Center required consistent HR support to ensure continuity of operations and adherence to employment law and licensing requirements. Nancy and her team remained engaged and responsive, helping us navigate workforce needs while maintaining compliance in a highly regulated environment.
 
Her accessibility, communication, and commitment to meeting deadlines have helped our team move key work forward. I appreciate Nancy’s collaborative style and her commitment to supporting leadership with clarity and integrity. She has been a trusted partner as we continue to stabilize and strengthen our organization.”
Mike González, Executive Director, Gateway Center of Monterey County